[email protected] 07570 630782
News

The GCF write an open letter to Matt Zarb-Cousin

By Gamblers Consumer Forum

Following the encouraging comments on the issue of affordability checks made by Matt Zarb-Cousin on the Barstewards Enquiry podcast last month, the GCF have written him an open letter to clarify points and seek support for an AI solution in tackling gambling harm. The letter is reproduced below:

We at the Gamblers Consumer Forum listened with great interest to your recent interview on the Barstewards Enquiry Pod. As we too are committed to effective measures to tackle gambling harm, it was good to hear your views. The vast majority we agreed with, especially around the past behaviour, the use of AML to delay withdrawals, and the lack of prescriptive guidance from the Gambling Commission.

We have also raised the ineffectiveness of affordability checks for some time as a tool to tackle gambling harm, and it was heartening to hear you allude to supporting the scrapping of these for the horseracing industry. Given that we understand from your interview, and our own sources, that the affordability pilot is running into a number of issues, it would seem opportune to look at alternatives to the current failing safeguards.

We would however welcome clarification on some points, as we have also listened to your recent interview on the Guiding Light podcast. You referred to your concerns around the PGSI screening and stated that the amount of bets and how much you deposit being the indicator of harm, also citing that 5 bets a week or month are a safe level of consumption. In addition to this, you stated that the industry should be embracing a model of low spend, high customer, high regulation, big compliance costs that shuts out little operators. You seemed to suggest that so long as an addictive agent is regulated enough, it will no longer carry a risk. This seems to be at odds with other well known addictive products, such as Class A drugs, which are among the most illegally and culturally regulated substances in the world, and yet we still see Class A drug consumption, and its associated mortality, across the globe. 

You discuss further this notion that the industry is the sole driver of addiction, but this appears to be at odds with studies into consumption behaviour. By way of illustration, a Cochrane Review (2014) that looked into the banning or restriction of alcohol advertising on the amount of alcohol consumed found a lack of robust evidence to support that one affected the other (Siegfried et al). This rather succinctly describes the crux of the argument: given the vast majority of adults are exposed, through many different mediums, to addictive agents on a daily basis (food, shopping, alcohol, smoking, gambling, smart phones), why isn’t the rate of addiction so much higher? Far from ‘blaming’ individuals, is it not better to try and understand through genuine clinical and neurological insight, as to why some individuals become addicted over others, thus offering a more personalised treatment plan and a deeper understanding of the nature of addiction altogether? The current approach of sub-clinical and financial evaluations would yield a number of ‘problem gamblers’ far beyond the capacity we have to treat them, and does a disservice to those addicted to gambling, as well as their loved ones, given there is no evidence that 1) addiction can be categorised by loss, as Matt Gaskell as publicly alluded to a number of times, and 2) that affordability checks are effective in tackling gambling harm. 

The Gamblers Consumer Forum have recently put forward to DCMS the artificial intelligence harm market solution offer by Mindway AI. Their technology is used by millions and has been implemented successfully in a number of jurisdictions, both privately and by governments. We believe this can act as an effective alternative to affordability checks and can point gamblers at risk of harm to treatment. We would welcome your support to this as an alternative to affordability checks. This would allow Britain to become the world leader in safer gambling, while ensuring we remain a free society that is mindful of the finite resources we have to treat those addicted.