[email protected] 07570 630782
News

The GCF write to the Gambling Commission to raise concerns about estimates and statistics used by NIESR around the costs of the gambling.

By Gamblers Consumer Forum

The GCF have written to the Gambling Commission to raise concerns about estimates and statistics used by NIESR around the costs of the gambling. As per the letter below:, a number of figures were quoted at the Labour Party conference this week which the GCF believe are dubious. We are therefore asking the Gambling Commission to look into the claims.

We are writing regarding concerns that have been raised with us following the Social Market Foundation event held at the Labour Party conference in Liverpool on the 24th September. The event was live streamed and is available to view on Youtube.

At this meeting, Professor Adrian Pabst of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (‘NIESR’) comments that the costs to the state of ‘problem gambling’ could now be in the region of £5bn a year.

It is our understanding that the figure was arrived at by the following process: Last year NIESR published its report on the ‘fiscal costs and benefits of problem gambling’. It asserted that harmful gambling cost the British taxpayer at least £1.4bn a year – a figure that hinged on its estimate that 0.7% of adults in Britain were ‘problem gamblers’. Since then, yourselves  at the Gambling Commission has published the Gambling Survey for Great Britain (‘GSGB’), which indicates a prevalence rate of 2.5% instead. Professor Pabst appears therefore to have upweighted his previous estimate in line with this new figure. His calculation therefore relies on grossing up the problem gambling rate from the GSGB to a population figure – and this appears to be a breach of the Commission’s guidance on how the GSGB should be used (the GSGB “should not be used to to gross up the prevalence of problem gambling or the consequences of gambling to whole population (until further work is completed)”). Professor Pabst linked his new estimate of fiscal costs to the need to enact further regulatory reforms – in breach of the Commission’s rules for the use of regulatory settlements (“Regulatory settlement funds will not be applied for the purposes of campaigning or lobbying”).

Turning next to the report itself, approximately 60% of NIESR’s 2023 cost estimate refers to excess use of Universal Credit by ‘problem gamblers’; and was calculated using data from the ONS ‘Wealth and Assets Survey’. The ONS survey however, contains no information whatsoever that might be used to identify ‘problem gambling’; and so NIESR appears to have developed its own formula. It decided for example, that anyone who had won £500 or more in the previous two years and was not working due to ill health must be an ‘at risk gambler’. Its criteria for identifying ‘problem gamblers’ meanwhile, was so speculative that it encompassed people who did not gamble at all. In this way, NIESR arrived at a ‘problem gambling’ cost estimate of £800m a year based on at best guesswork (and this presumably rises to £2.9bn using the Pabst rate of inflation).

The next biggest area of alleged cost involves excess use of hospital inpatient services and was based on results from the 2007 NHS Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey. This dataset does at least contain estimates of ‘problem gambling’; but NIESR’s figure of £447m a year in costs (32% of the total) was based on a statistically inadequate sample of just nine survey respondents; and the calculation was neither provided nor explained. The remaining 11% of costs were derived using similarly weak methods. The report contains a number of flaws (including basic errors of addition, multiplication and division) and inconsistencies (it provided no fewer than four different cost estimates for excess use of GP surgeries by ‘problem gamblers’).

This report was funded via a £140,050 regulatory settlement approved by the Gambling Commission. Professor Pabst disclosed this week that the Commission had awarded further funds for a follow-up study (conducted by NIESR and the University of Glasgow at a cost of £402,184), despite the clear and obvious obvious problems with the initial NIESR.

We would be grateful therefore if you could provide answers to the following questions:

1) Does the Gambling Commission consider the NIESR estimates of the fiscal costs of problem gambling to be methodologically sound?

2) How does the NIESR report the aims of the National Strategy to Reduce Gambling Harms?

3) Will the Gambling Commission investigate NIESR for breach of rules regarding the use of regulatory settlements?

4) Why did the Gambling Commission not review and quality assure the NIESR report before awarding a further £402,184 to a follow-up project?

5) Is Professor Pabst in breach of Commission guidance on the use of the GSGB for grossing up “the prevalence of problem gambling or the consequences of gambling to whole population”?

We have copied the Gambling Minister Baroness Twycross into this email and given she was present at the event, we would be grateful if you could copy her into the response.

The GCF are reliant on supporter donations. To read more about our missions and how to support us, please visit here.